Bidʿah Has No Borders: Localization Is Not a Condition for Refuting Innovation
Al-ʿAllāmah ʿUbayd ibn ʿAbdullāh al-Jābirī
A response to the notion that refutation of misguidance should only come from the land it originated in.
Bidʿah Has No Borders: Localization Is Not a Condition for Refuting Innovation
Al-ʿAllāmah ʿUbayd ibn ʿAbdullāh al-Jābirī
A response to the notion that refutation of misguidance should only come from the land it originated in.


Ibn ʿAbbās (رضي الله عنهما) said: By Allāh! I do not think there is anyone on the face of the earth today whose destruction is more beloved to Shayṭān than mine.
It was said: How so?
He replied: By Allāh! He introduces an innovation in the east or the west, then a man carries it to me. So when it reaches me, I crush it with the Sunnah, and it is thrown back at him (Shayṭān) just as he brought it out.[1]
Shaykh ʿUbayd al-Jābirī (رحمه الله) commented:
Look! Today, a statement has appeared: “The ‘people of the land’ are more entitled and know better.”[2]
So, for example, the people of al-Shām, al-Ḥijāz, al-ʿIrāq and Najd should not interfere in whatever occurs in Egypt, because the people of Egypt know better. This is how things have become in some regions. When a man is refuted, they retort, “The people of his land know better.” This is incorrect.
This is one of the greatest doors through which the innovators enter. The Sunnah is the Sunnah, and bidʿah is bidʿah. Bidʿah is bidʿah whether it occurs in Yemen, al-Ḥijāz, al-ʿIrāq, Najd or Egypt. Wherever it occurs, it is still bidʿah.
As for social and societal matters, every land has its own customs, such as their official working hours, their (ways of) buying and selling, and other specific permissible matters. All people have customs in their lands, but what governs them is the Sharīʿah. If the custom of any land opposes the Sharīʿah of Allāh, then the Sharīʿah is the ruling authority that prevails over all else. But matters in which the Sharīʿah has not intervened remain permissible.[3]
Endnotes
[1] Al-Lālakāʾī in Sharḥ Uṣūl Iʿtiqād Ahl al-Sunnah wa-al-Jamāʿah, vol. 1, pg. 61, no. 12
[2] Translator’s note: This is not the same as the ḥadīth principle that the people of a narrator’s land know him better. That principle is about facts: whether a narrator was reliable, how his countrymen know better regarding his personal condition than visitors or people abroad. It is also used to accept criticism, when the people of one’s own land dispraise him and how their criticism is given precedence over the praise of outsiders. However, bidʿah is a Sharʿī ruling. It is the same in every land, and it is judged by the people of knowledge wherever they are. The statement refuted here is used to reject criticism and to silence the people of knowledge of other lands only because they are not from that land. This was the case in Yemen when Muḥammad al-Imām was refuted by the scholars in Saudi Arabia for signing a futile pact with the Ḥouthīs, then some of the Mashayikh of Yemen defended him with this statement that ‘the people of the land know best regarding its condition’.
[3] Source: al-Fawāʾid al-Majmūʿah min al-Liqāʾāt al-Maftūḥah, pg. 71.
Compiled and translated by: Munīb al-Ṣumālī
⚠️ Donate to the Yearly Digital Daʿwah Sponsorship Drive – $20,000 Target
Become a sponsoring publisher of free islamic content to 10s of 1000s of people monthly.
Most Popular: Last 30 Days

In Imām al-Albānī’s Own Words: The Islamic Right to Repel Oppression and Seek Just Retribution

The Manners of the Scholars in Correcting One Another: Guarding the People from the Prestige of the Mistaken












